Easy Air Fryer Stuffed Mushrooms Recipe

These Air Fryer Stuffed Mushrooms are the best kind you will ever make. Stuffed Mushrooms are filled with cream cheese, bit of jalapenos & topped with everything bagel seasoning. Since it is a quick & easy recipe, you can make it anytime to please the crowd. 

Post may contain affiliate links. Please read disclosure here.

Easy Air Fryer Stuffed Mushrooms Recipe

This appetizer is so easy to make ahead of time. And the best part is that the stuffing can be easily adapted to personal liking. It is a vegetarian and gluten-free recipe. 

This is an easy appetizer and such a crowd pleaser. You can make it with just handful ingredients. The Everything Bagel Seasoning adds such nice crunch to it without loading up on the carbs.

It is a perfect Low-Carb & Keto Vegetarian Recipe. Even my children loved it.

Although I have stuffed these mushrooms with cream cheese & pickled jalapenos, you can sub it with artichokes & spinach, olives, capers and anything of your choice. 

Air fryer is a blessing since it is time efficient and saves the kitchen from heating up especially in summers. 

Check out our delicious VEGETARIAN AIR FRYER RECIPES here 

Air fryer Frittata, Air Fryer FALAFEL, Air fryer Banana Bread, Air fryer Baby Potatoes, Air fryer Fajitas, Air-fryer Tofu in Asian Sauce, Sweet Potatoes, Apple Strudel, Sweet Potato Fries, Hand Pies, Bread Rolls, Salted Nuts, Peanuts, Air fryer Green Peas,Air Fryer Green Beans, Air Fryer Banana Chips, Peas Puff Pastry Air Fryer Stuffed Poblano Peppers, Air Fryer Apple Crisp Recipe, Air Fryer Calzone Recipe , Air Fryer Croissant Rolls with spinach & ricotta, Shishito peppers and more.

What are the ingredients of Air Fryer Stuffed Mushrooms?

As I mentioned above, this recipe needs only handful ingredients –

Baby Portabella Mushrooms

Cream Cheese at room temperature 

Garlic

Pickled Jalapenos

Parsley

Everything Bagel Seasoning

Cooking Oil Spray

Kitchen Gadgets used in the recipe

Air fryer

Food Processor

Air fryer Accessories

Mixing Bowl

Measuring Cups & Spoon

Chopping board & Knife

Kitchen Colander

Kitchen Tongs

How to make Air Fryer Stuffed Mushrooms?

Now it is a 3 steps simple and easy recipe.

Prepare the Mushrooms

Wash the mushrooms thoroughly in Food Processor and add Pickled Jalapenos, cloves of garlic and mushroom stems to it. Process them fine. Further add dry Parsley & soft cream cheese to the processor and blend till mixed well.

Take the cream cheese stuffing out in a Mixing Bowl and set aside.

Stuff the Mushrooms

Now take one mushroom cap at a time. Fill the hole with the cream cheese stuffing. Sprinkle the stuffed mushrooms with a bit of Everything Bagel Seasoning . Further finish all the mushroom caps likewise and set aside to air fry.

Air Fry the Stuffed Mushrooms

Preheat the Air fryer at 390*F for 2-3 minutes. Now spray the air fryer basket with a Cooking Oil Spray. Further place the stuffed mushrooms gently inside the basket one at a time. Do not over crowd the basket. You have to air fry these in 2 batches. 

Now air fry the stuffed mushrooms for 8-10 minutes. The timing depends upon the size of the mushrooms. Smaller mushrooms might get done in 7-8 minutes. Larger mushrooms might take 10-12 minutes. You can check the done-ness by seeing the color change of the cheese stuffing and the stuffing sits stiffer on the mushrooms.

Once done, take these out with Kitchen Tongs and let them rest for 2-3 minutes before serving. Serve these warm with some Buffalo Sauce or sauce of your choice.

Tip for making Stuffed Mushrooms

As you get ready to to make the stuffed mushrooms, you will want to blend all the ingredients in a food processor.  This gives them the perfect consistency for stuffing. 

How do you avoid the mushrooms sticking in the basket?

I normally spray the air fryer basket with the cooking spray or olive oil spray. Also I spray the mushrooms with the cooking oil lightly.

Can you freeze stuffed mushrooms?

You can freeze them before you plan to cook them. Although my personal preference is to cook them fresh. This is such an easy recipe with minimum prep. You actually can easily pull it off on time. You can prepare the stuffing in advance.

Can I double the recipe?

Yes easily. You can double the recipe. It will take 3-4 rounds to air fry all.

How to store the left-overs?

You can easily refrigerate the leftovers in an air tight container.

How to re-heat the refrigerated left-overs?

Put them in air fryer and air fry for 2-3 minutes till warm.

Can I make Stuffed Mushrooms in the oven?

Absolutely. Preheat the oven at 400*F. Bake on a baking sheet inside the oven for 15 minutes or till done.

What are the other choices for stuffing?

1. Use any cheese of your choice like ricotta or cheddar or gouda.
2. Replace pickled jalapenos with fresh chopped jalapenos.
3. You may add canned artichokes and fresh/thawed spinach combo.
4. The olives and pizza sauce with cheese will be yummy too.

Simplyvegetarian777 Vegan Instant Pot Curry Recipes

Chana Masala, Saag Aloo, Rajma Masala (red kidney beans curry), Palak Paneer, Aloo Baingan ( potato eggplant curry), Lobiya (Black eye Peas curry) and more.

Simplyvegetarian777  INSTANT POT VEGAN ASIAN RECIPES

Red Thai Curry, Green Thai Curry, Kung Pao Noodles, Thai Curry Noodles, Tom Yum

Simplyvegetarian777 Instant Pot Desserts

Pumpkin Cake, Pumpkin Cheesecake, Holiday Coffee Cake, Chocolate Cheesecake, New York Cheesecake and many more.

Simplyvegetarian777  Instant Pot Vegetarian Soups

Broccoli Cheddar Soup, Panera Corn Chowder, Olive Garden Minestrone Soup, Poblano Cheddar Soup, Taco Soup, Mixed Beans Chili, Hot & Sour Soup,

Wonton Soup, Wild Rice & Mushroom Soup and more.

You can follow us on Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest & Twitter & You-tube for regular updates. And don’t forget to sign up for our E-Letter whenever we publish a new post.

Air Fryer Stuffed Mushrooms Recipe – Vegetarian & Gluten-free

I am sure you are going to make this recipe soon. Please leave your feedback in the comments section.

Thanks,

Sonal